How to be notified about new members?

I would like our "stewards" (they're our welcome team) to receive notifications when a new member has been approved. But I can't quite figure out how to make that work. I tried setting the notifications for one of them as shown on the file below but she didn't get a notice when someone joined or when that new person was approved. What to do???

As the master admin, I get notifications for new members but I don't want to make all our stewards master admins.
updated by @deb-w: 09/07/17 03:28:09PM

Does your welcome person receive OTHER notifications that they have set 'yes' to?... is it ONLY the new member notification that she has not gotten? That would help determine if their site notifications were winding up in her spam filter. The 'new member notification' setting is working properly for my 'welcome wagon' members and moderators.

Also- are you familiar with the 'profile admin' quota?- it's for assigning members to become moderators but NOT Master Admins.... which means they can edit/delete other members' content and profiles (hence the name Profile Admin), they have access to your dashboard, but they CANNOT access the backend codes, skins, modules, templates etc. That way they can moderate troublesome members or disable spammers, but they cannot mess up the critical structure of your site.


--
...just another satisfied Jamroom customer.
Migrated from Ning to Jamroom June 2015