my list of things ning migrators will mkiss
Ning To Jamroom
Hi Brian,
The basic problem I see with forums is:
1) The left column is showing the originators profile information. Irrelevant to the thread, and a waste of space which could be better put to use linking to other forum categories and such, even ad space, or editable space would be better.
See an example here -
http://indiegospel.org/forum
Notice how there are categories in the left column. Each category is searchable independently and has it's own RSS feed... There is editable space in the right column but I wouldn't miss that.
On an actual discussions the left column is hidden allowing a more full screen view. At all times the originators profile is linked so it's still profilecentric, but there is more of a "Community" feel to it all and less obtuse about the profile.
2) Having an RSS module, and having RSS set-up by default in key areas (as already done with blogs) is two different things. Ning migrants (and newbies in general) have enough of a learning curve in front of them, without also have to figure out how to add RSS to the site activity feed and forums, etc.
For instance, I pass my site feed from Ning through a tool to make automated Facebook and Twitter posts, which also drives my Newspaper. All of that will collapse.
3) Jamroom has some pretty cool featuring ability based on quotas and profile numbers. However, Ning had a button only visible to admins which allowed a piece of content, or member, to be featured in their category. What I'm saying is, some will miss that functionality.
4) Groups are a "big deal" will be a "deal breaker" for some. Here are some samples -
http://indiegospel.org/groups
Notice how they still link to the originators profile, but feel like a "separate space" not a "glorified" profile page. What they provide, which Jamroom doesn't currently provide is:
- a WYSIWYG editor for the main area.
- a heading area for title description etc.
- The ability for for one member to message all members.
- The ability for members to send invites to their friends/followers
- The ability for an admin to invite all network members.
- A group forum whose discussions are isolated from the community forums and from other group forums.
- Group admin tools like adding deleting members, assigning group admins, etc.
- The ability to make pages which stay isolated to that group and automatically linked within it.
- RSS generation for export of discussions and rendering of RSS for importation of external feed.
Jamroom currently fails on most of these and if you are looking for a way to really have a "selling point" or "drawing card" add group specific chat. That will "make a better Jamroom that fits our needs" and outclass Ning in this area, so as to make migration a "no brainer".
updated by @ken-rich: 12/29/14 09:23:54AM